| Children |
| | 1. Thomas Hampton BENENHALEY, Sr., b. 13/18 Feb 1837, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 27 Dec 1919, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 82 years) |
| | 2. William BENENHALEY, b. 1838, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 1895, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 57 years) |
| | 3. Living |
| | 4. Mary Ann(e) BENENHALEY, b. 7 Mar 1842, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 1 Jan 1935, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 92 years) |
| | 5. Living |
| | 6. Alice BENENHALEY, b. 1850 |
| | 7. Enoch/Enock BENENHALEY, b. 10 Mar 1851, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 31 Aug 1912, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 61 years) |
| | 8. Joseph BENENHALEY, III, b. 1854/53, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 1923, Sumter County, South Carolina  |
| | 9. Martha BENENHALEY, b. 1855 |
| | 10. Noah BENENHALEY, b. 1859, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 21 May 1939, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 80 years) |
|