| Children |
| | 1. Martha BENENHALEY, b. 11 Jan 1878 d. 5 Feb 1917 (Age 39 years) |
| | 2. William “Willie” BENENHALEY, b. Sep 1884 d. 1943 (Age 58 years) |
| | 3. Charles BENENHALEY, b. 5 May 1885 d. 26 Feb 1904 (Age 18 years) |
| | 4. Aaron BENENHALEY, b. Jan 1889 |
| | 5. Edward BENENHALEY, b. 20 Apr 1891 d. 29 Apr 1952 (Age 61 years) |
| | 6. James M. BENENHALEY, b. Mar 1894 |
| | 7. Mary Magdalene BENENHALEY, b. 28 Jun 1894/2, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 17 Jun 1971, Tuomey Hospital, Sumter, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 68 years) |
| | 8. Katie Jane BENENHALEY, b. 28 May 1899, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 31 Jan 1965 (Age 65 years) |
| | 9. Dollie Selina BENENHALEY, b. 6 Mar 1900 d. 25 Oct 1992 (Age 92 years) |
| | 10. Nora BENENHALEY, b. 2 Jun 1902, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 17 Oct 1970, Tuomey Hospital, Sumter, Sumter County, South Carolina (Age 68 years) |
| | 11. Infant daughter BENENHALEY, b. 11 Oct 1906 d. 11 Oct 1906 (Age 0 years) |
| | 12. Solomon BENENHALEY d. Bef 28 Jan 2020 |
| | 13. Mamie BENENHALEY |
| | 14. N. Mitchell BENENHALEY, b. Sumter, Sumter County, South Carolina d. 14 Mar 1998, at his home, Eastover, South Carolina  |
|